Your best influencers aren't on Instagram—they're already in your Shopify store.
The customers who've bought from you multiple times, who leave glowing reviews, who tag your brand in their posts—they're the ones who can authentically represent your products. Yet most Shopify store owners miss them entirely, instead spending time hunting for random creators on social media with massive followings but little genuine connection to their brand.
This guide walks you through three approaches to finding influencers: manual methods, tools, and automation. By the end, you'll know exactly who your influencers are and how to recruit them.
## The Problem With Traditional Influencer Discovery
Most brands find influencers the hard way: Instagram searching, influencer marketplaces, or hiring agencies. The results? High costs, slow timelines, and influencers who may not actually align with your brand.
Here's what goes wrong:
The better approach: Start with your own customers.
## Method 1: Manual Influencer Discovery (The DIY Approach)
If you want to start finding influencers with zero tools, here's how:
### Step 1: Identify Your Repeat Customers
Open your Shopify admin and look at your customer list. Filter for customers who've made multiple purchases. These repeat buyers are more likely to be influencers than one-time purchasers.
What to look for:
### Step 2: Check Their Social Profiles
Visit each customer's social media (Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn). Look for:
### Step 3: Research Social Reach
Even if a customer has a smaller follower count, they might be influential in a niche. Check:
### Step 4: Create a Spreadsheet
Build a simple tracker:
| Customer Name | Email | Orders | LTV | Instagram Handle | Followers | Engagement Rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jane Doe | jane@... | 4 | $520 | @janedoe | 8.2K | 4.2% | Fashion blogger, authentic |
This manual approach takes hours but gives you a baseline understanding of who your influencers might be.
Drawback: It doesn't scale. With 10,000 customers, this is impossible to do by hand.
## Method 2: Using Tools for Influencer Discovery
Several Shopify apps and platforms can automate discovery:
### Shopify-Native Tools
Shopify Orders API: Advanced users can build custom queries to find repeat customers and analyze their spending patterns.
Email Integration: Link Shopify to Klaviyo or Mailchimp and segment high-value customers. These segments often overlap with influencers.
### Third-Party Influencer Platforms
Upfluence, AspireIQ, Klear: These platforms let you search influencers by follower count, engagement, and audience demographics. But they only show creators they've indexed (often Instagram creators), not your actual customers.
HypeAuditor, Social Blade: Analyze creator engagement and audience quality. Useful for vetting influencers once you've identified them.
### Customer Intelligence Apps
This is where the real magic happens. Apps like SonarID analyze your Shopify order data to identify customers with influencer potential—even if they're not famous yet.
These tools look beyond follower count and examine:
Why this matters: A customer who's bought from you 5 times is a better influencer than a random creator with 100K followers. They've already proven they love your brand.
## Method 3: Automated Influencer Identification (The Modern Approach)
The best approach combines Shopify data with automation:
### How It Works
1. Connect your Shopify store to a customer intelligence platform
2. Analyze order patterns to find repeat customers and high-value buyers
3. Score customers on influencer potential using metrics like:
- Repeat purchase frequency
- Average order value
- Customer lifetime value
- Engagement signals (from email opens, clicks, etc.)
4. Surface micro-influencers you didn't know you had
5. Automatically flag new influencers as they reach certain thresholds
This approach is fast, scalable, and discovers influencers hiding in your customer base.
Real example: A fashion brand using this approach discovered 47 micro-influencers in their customer base—all with 5K-50K followers, high engagement, and existing love for the brand. They'd been customers for an average of 2 years.
## Finding Influencers by Type
Different influencer types require different discovery methods:
### Micro-Influencers (10K-100K followers)
Often found in your customer base. Look for repeat buyers with strong engagement.
### Nano-Influencers (1K-10K followers)
Almost always in your customer base. These often convert better than larger creators.
### Macro-Influencers (100K+ followers)
Rarely customers. Typically found through influencer platforms or agencies.
### Niche/Vertical Experts
Found by analyzing customer content. Are they posting about your specific category?
Pro tip: Most brands should focus on micro and nano-influencers first. They have better engagement, lower costs, and authentic audiences.
## Red Flags When Identifying Influencers
Not every repeat customer is an influencer. Watch out for:
Use tools to analyze engagement authenticity before reaching out.
## Next Steps: From Identification to Recruitment
Once you've identified influencers, the real work begins:
1. Analyze their audience to ensure alignment
2. Personalize your outreach (show them you know they're a customer)
3. Create a gifting strategy (see our Complete Guide to Gifting Influencers)
4. Set expectations about what you're asking them to do
5. Track performance to measure ROI
## The Bottom Line
Finding influencers on Shopify doesn't require expensive agencies or Instagram hunting. Your best influencers are already customers—you just need to find them.
Start with your repeat customers. Then use tools or automation to identify the ones with genuine influence and authentic audiences.
The brands winning at influencer marketing aren't using generic platforms. They're mining their own customer data to find advocates who already love their brand.
---
## Ready to Find Your Influencers?
SonarID automatically identifies influencers hiding in your Shopify store—no manual hunting required. See your micro-influencers, VIPs, and brand advocates in minutes.
[Start your free trial] and discover who your actual influencers are.
---
## Related Articles